Saturday, August 1, 2020

Water, Water Everywhere, and All of it is Holy

There is a fun college chemistry assignment that involves calculating (roughly) how many air molecules from Julius Caesar’s last dying gasp will be in the breath you are about to inhale. You make some reasonable assumptions about the height and density of the atmosphere, and use the gas laws to reach an estimate. It’s perfect for making college chemistry sophomores think, to use their new knowledge in non-technical but useful ways. The answer is that about one molecule in every breath you breathe was also in Caesar’s last dying breath. 

 

I wanted to do the same thing for water, because water is more intimate; it doesn’t just go in and out of our lungs, it lives in us as part of us before being excreted. I was astounded at the results. 

 

Since I’m in the U.S. and was raised in Christianity, I’m going to use Jesus for my calculations, but you could pick anyone who lived more than a century or two ago and get similar results. Let’s assume Jesus was an average Joe, drinking about 2 liters of water per day. Over 40 years, that’s 30,000 liters of water. Talk about holy relics! No water could possibly be more holy than water that actually passed through his body, so I’ll call these 30,000 liters “Holy Water,” and the molecules that made them up I’ll call “Holy Molecules.” Those Holy Molecules are now spread all over the planet thanks to the water cycle. There are 1.0x1030of them.*

 

The total volume of the oceans is 1.37x10cubic kilometers. All the fresh water in all the glaciers, lakes, rivers, and groundwater makes up only 2.5%, which is negligible for my purposes here. There are 1015 cubic centimeters in a cubic kilometer, so the volume of the oceans is 1.37x1024cm3.

 

Jesus’ 30,000 liters is thirty million cm3. Dividing it by the volume of the oceans gives us the fraction of HW among all Earth water: 2.2x10-17. That’s a very small fraction—a drop in the ocean really—but it contains one hell of a lot of molecules. If that fraction of each cubic centimeter of water is Holy Molecules, then each cubic centimeter of water on this planet contains 668,000 Holy Molecules!

 

So grab a cup of water. Drink it. You just drank over 150 million Holy Molecules.§  Now they’re inside you, living as you. All water is holy water.  

 

Yes, I see you there, waving your arms and puffing out your cheeks about how we can’t assume perfect mixing. “What about the deep oceans, where ocean currents don’t flow,” you ask, “where water molecules might sit for eons without mixing with surface ones? And what about all that water locked up in glaciers since before the Ice Age? What about…” 

 

I hear you. But think about it; if we took those non-mixing waters into account, it would decrease the volume we used for the oceans, which would only increase the portion of Holy Molecules in your glass. My calculation is a low-end estimate, a minimum. Being more precise about which waters mix would only increase the holiness of the water in your glass. 

 

For those who think I played a dirty trick by neglecting the planet’s reserves of fresh water, taking them into account would yield 651,000 Holy Molecules per cm3instead of 668,000. For a cup of water, the answer is the same after rounding. 

 

Every cup of water you drink contains over 150 million water molecules that passed through Jesus’ body during his lifetime. Some of those—some small number of them but still a few in every glass of wine, soda, milk, beer or spring-water—were in his body when he died.

 

All water is holy water. 

 

I’ll raise a glass to that.  Cheers. 

 

 

* Water is 1g/ml and has a molecular mass of 18.015g/mole. 

  30,000 liters = 30 million ml = 30 million grams. 

  Divide that by 18.015 g/mol = 1.67x106moles. 

  Multiply that by Avogadro’s number (6.01x1023) = 1.0x1030molecules. 

 

† Water is 1g/ml and has a molecular mass of 18.015g/mole. 

   1g divided by 18.015g/mol = .0555…moles. 

   That times Avogadro’s number = 3.34x1022molecules in each cm3.

   Multiplying by the HW fraction of that = 668,000 Holy Molecules in each cm3.

 

§ 1C = 236 cm3, so multiply 668,000 by 236 = 157.6 million per cup. 

Sunday, July 19, 2020

Grains of Sand and Stars in the Universe

In writing my book,[1] I tried to track down some well-known facts to their sources, only to find that some well-known facts aren’t facts at all. For example, there is a widely bandied-about figure on the number of grains of sand on the earth, credited to a “study” done by “researchers at the University of Hawaii.” 

I had to use the WayBack Machine to find the “study,” which turns out to be a rough estimate done by a mathematician named Howard C. McAllister. It was never published in any research journal. Beyond that, McAllister was only trying to estimate the beach sand on the earth; he did not include any deserts. 

His old figure for beach sand is 7.5 x 1018, and may be found here. Yeah, click there and check it out. It’s hardly a “study.” It’s an order-of-magnitude estimate. A nice one, but far from definitive, and nothing like a research paper. 

I’m going to complete McAllister’s estimate, in hopes that eventually people will find this post for a more comprehensive estimate. In the same spirit as his original, this will be an order-of-magnitude calculation; sticklers for specifics can write their own blogs. My work here is NOT definitive! 

The fourteen[2] largest deserts according to geology.com are:

Antactica                 (no sand)
The Arctic               (no sand)
Sahara                     3,500,000 square miles
Arabian                   1,000,000 mi2
Gobi                         500,000
Patagonian            (more rocky than sandy)
Great Victoria        250,000           (shallow sand, mostly)
Kalahari                  220,000
Great Basin            190,000            (shallow sand, mostly)
Syrian                     190,000
Chihauhuan          175,000              (shallow sand, mostly)
Great Sandy          150,000
Kara Kum              135,000
Colorado Plateau 130,000              (shallow sand)
Gibson Desert      120,000

All the other deserts further down the list add up (roughly) to another 700,000 square miles. 

That makes a total of 7,260,000 square miles. That’s a lot. Let’s assume (for no good reason and with no evidence whatsoever) that most of the deserts with dunes average ten meters for depth of sand, and that the shallow ones average one meter in depth. The former is probably low and the latter one high, but they are easy numbers, and probably within an order of magnitude. 

Converting square miles to square meters then multiplying and summing (see table below) that yields an overall volume of 1.71 x 1014 cubic meters of sand in deserts alone. 

Using the same grain volume (1 mm3) used by the UHI mathematicians, we multiply our deserts’ volumes by the number of cubic millimeters in a cubic meter (1,000,000,000) to get: 

1.71 x 1023 grains of sand in the world’s deserts.

Whoa. The beaches are totally eclipsed by this number. Adding them together changes nothing.[3]  Sand on beaches is comparatively insignificant. 

The number of galaxies in the visible universe is currently estimated at two trillion (2 x 1012)Each galaxy contains, on average, between 100 billion and 400 billion stars (solar systems), or 1 x 1011 to 4 x 1011.

That gives a range for stars of 2 x 1023 (close to sand!) to 8 x 1023

It is still true: There are more solar systems in the visible universe than grains of sand on the earth. Just barely. Same order of magnitude, for sure. The weakest part of my reasoning is the depth of sand in the world's deserts. It could easily be ten times what I assumed here, which could put sand in the lead over stars, depending on the average number of stars in each galaxy. 

I hope that's helpful. 

DESERTSIZE (mi2)AREA (m2)Sandy?DEPTHVOLUME
Sahara3.50E+069.07E+12109.07E+13
Arabian1.00E+062.59E+12102.59E+13
Gobi5.00E+051.30E+12101.30E+13
Patagonian0.00E+00rocky0.00E+00
Great Victoria2.50E+056.48E+11shallow16.48E+11
Kalahari2.20E+055.70E+11105.70E+12
Great Basin1.90E+054.92E+11shallow14.92E+11
Syrian1.90E+054.92E+11104.92E+12
Chihauhuan1.75E+054.53E+11shallow14.53E+11
Great Sandy1.50E+053.89E+11103.89E+12
Kara Kum1.35E+053.50E+11103.50E+12
Colorado Plateau1.30E+053.37E+11shallow13.37E+11
Gibson Desert1.20E+053.11E+11103.11E+12
Other7.00E+051.81E+12101.81E+13
TOTAL7.26E+061.88E+131.71E+14
If each grain of sand takes 1 cubic mm ---->>1.71E+23
(grains)




[1] Working title: Implications; The Interfaith Promise of Science
[2] Just because. 
[3] 1.71 x 1023 + 7.5 x 1018 = 1.710075 x 1023 which rounds to 1.71 x 1023.